24h購物| | PChome| 登入
2009-02-26 02:28:22| 人氣679| 回應5 | 上一篇 | 下一篇

Tasting - Two Peaty Monsters

推薦 0 收藏 0 轉貼0 訂閱站台


品飲日期: 2009/2/24

Ardbeg Supernova 2001/2009 Advanced Committee Release 58.9% OB
C: light yellow
23 N: melon peer, toffee, vanilla, caramel(milk candy), follow by some whote flowers, rich peat sweet, some kelp, then some whit sugar,龍鬚糖,紅毛丹
21 T: light, dry and spicy, very good impact w/ lots of peaty burst out, whit chocolate, a little salty, pepper, good txture
22 F: medium, more peat, heather, white pepper, finish in some white fruit, peaches, pear, some hint of mint. sweet and good extension
21 B: balanced, especially good for nosing, active and variant, a young Renaissance! but more paety than it, a little pitty for tasting, and I prefer Corryvreckan

PS. 2001/2009 100ppm 7% French Oak, 13% Spanish Sherry cask, rest were ex-bourbon

Bruichladdich Octomore 5Yo Edition 01.1 63.5% OB B#1020
C: light yellow
22 N: lots of lots of peat, some heather, sea weed, a little vanilla, cream and lemon pie, high alc
20 T: light -> medium, stunning peat and dry, very strong impact, some white chocolate, a little salty, smoky w/ some baked wood cask at the end of tongue
21 F: long, rich and thick peat, a littl vanilla, cream, white chocolate, but quite flat at the end
20 B: some how balanced, but the body is quite heavy w/ lots of peat and dry, cream, bitterness, not very drinkable

台長: Hertford
人氣(679) | 回應(5)| 推薦 (0)| 收藏 (0)| 轉寄
全站分類: 不分類 | 個人分類: Single Malt Whisky |
此分類下一篇:Tasting - 山岡先生訪台一支會(一)
此分類上一篇:Tasting - 二月份社團品飲Mortlach酒廠

susc
看來趙兄對Ardbeg Supernova的評價比Bruichladdich Octomore高些.印象中Octomore是超高泥煤度的首次嘗試,不過Supernova是2001蒸餾,Octomore是年齡5年的產品,怎麼看都覺得Supernova早於Octomore,是這樣嗎??還是我的觀念有誤??
2009-02-28 23:05:48
版主回應
其實這次我第二次喝Octomore,感覺跟上次差不多.不過若跟Supernova相較,的確有明顯差距.Supernova酒體就像其年齡明顯較Octomore成熟些,但不若十年的文藝復興來的好,仍稍嫌年輕了些.唯入口後爆炸性十足,口感顯然比Octomore來的易飲
2009-03-03 23:46:28
ljshen
根據 malt advocate magazine的 John Hansel所言, 確如 susc 所言, Ardbeg 的Supernova要比 Bruichladdich的 Octomore要老上數年, 所以在品嚐時, Ocotomore有股年輕酒的青澀滋味....當然現在時比不上 Supernova囉~ 但當二者的年份相當時, 誰好誰差就很難講了, 有待將來的再比試....
2009-03-01 21:32:53
版主回應
諶大哥說的好,看來Octomore會再繼續出,到時候再拿年齡相近的版本相比,一定很有趣~
2009-03-03 23:47:47
JM
問題在於,是誰老是把這種南喝的O咖酒裝出來?
2009-03-02 12:44:15
版主回應
不就是一位叫JM的嗎?
2009-03-03 23:48:24
susc
哈哈哈.........”不就是一位叫JM的嗎?”這句話好笑!!
2009-03-10 08:32:41
ljshen
哈哈哈 ~ JM.....
2009-03-23 08:50:05
是 (若未登入"個人新聞台帳號"則看不到回覆唷!)
* 請輸入識別碼:
請輸入圖片中算式的結果(可能為0) 
(有*為必填)
TOP
詳全文